RELATED PROJECTS

Site links

OFFOFFOFF Home

About OFFOFFOFF

Contact us

Film section

Film main page

Film archive

Audio index

Film links

Top 10 lists

Top 10 films of 2004
(Andrea, David, Joshua, Leslie)

Top 10 films of 2003
(Andrea, David, Joshua, Leslie)

Top 10 films of 2002

Top 10 films of 2001

Top 10 films of 2000

Top 10 films of 1999

All of our top 10 lists, 1999 - 2004

Current movies

Afterschool

Antichrist

Babies

Broken Embraces

Dare

District 9

The End of Poverty?

Fix

Food Beware

The Men Who Stare at Goats

Pirate Radio

Precious

Red Cliff

The September Issue

Festivals

Brooklyn International Film Festival

Human Rights Watch Film Festival

New York Film Festival

Archive

Complete archive

Recent reviews:

(500) Days of Summer

Anita O'Day: The Life of a Jazz Singer

The Art of the Steal

The Beetle

Blessed is the Match: The Life and Death of Hannah Senesh

Boy A

Brideshead Revisited

The Brothers Bloom

Burn After Reading

Cold Souls

The Duchess

Elegy

Enlighten Up! A Skeptic's Journey Into the World of Yoga

Five Minutes of Heaven

Flame and Citron

Frozen River

Happy-Go-Lucky

How to Lose Friends & Alienate People

The Human Condition

Hunger

Inglourious Basterds

King of Shadows

The Lemon Tree

Lorna's Silence

A Man Named Pearl

Man on Wire

Memorial Day

Mister Foe

Morning Light

My Führer

My One and Only

Paris

The Pervert's Guide to Cinema

Peter and Vandy

Police, Adjective

Pray the Devil Back to Hell

Profit Motive and the Whispering Wind

Rachel Getting Married

A Secret

Sleep Dealer

St. Trinian's

Thirst

Throw Down Your Heart

Valentino: The Last Emperor

What's the Matter with Kansas?

Wild Grass

Jay DiPietro

READER COMMENTS

Reader comments on Irreversible

Subject: Irreversible
Date: Feb 18, 2004

Sender: Tyler Durden

Previous | Next

Your review of "Irreversible" is the most ignorant gay-pride review I ever read. Is this country just full of "proud to be gay" pussies who are way too American to watch a work of art like "Irreversible"?

Previous: if you know films, this for BEST PICTURE | Next: Asking for a song

Respond to this message | Return to original article: Irreversible

Comment index:

Sorry for you from Mademoiselle, Mar 12, 2003

Re: Sorry for you from GD Williamson, Mar 18, 2003

Re: Sorry for you from Bryan, Sep 29, 2003

Re: Sorry for you from Tashtigo707, Apr 14, 2003

Re: Sorry for you from Perfume V, Jun 13, 2003

Re: Sorry for you from Seb, Oct 6, 2003

Re: Sorry for you from earlgrey, Oct 12, 2003

Re: Sorry for you from Sam, Nov 5, 2003

fascinating from irrelevant, Jan 10, 2004

Re: Sorry for you from FreeYOW, Jan 22, 2006

Re: Sorry for you from Rose, Sep 2, 2007

Don't listen to Joshy from Cory, Mar 13, 2003

worst... film... ever! from lunarfist, Mar 14, 2003

Irreversible did it's job from WebsCo, Aug 7, 2003

Re: worst... film... ever! from EJ, Aug 9, 2003

Re: worst... film... ever! from Matchfit, Sep 1, 2003

Re: worst... film... ever! from dcc, Aug 16, 2007

Death Wish from Geezer, Feb 14, 2004

Re: worst... film... ever! from Jo, Feb 15, 2004

Re: worst... film... ever! from DC, Aug 16, 2007

Re: worst... film... ever! from mastroiani, Jun 30, 2009

[no subject] from MJ, Mar 30, 2003

are you kidding? from tb7, Apr 1, 2003

Repulsive without merit from t c, Apr 16, 2003

Re: Repulsive without merit from CB, May 2, 2003

Re: Repulsive without merit from tie, Mar 15, 2004

Re: Repulsive without merit from Mimo Zus, Aug 17, 2004

Re: Repulsive without merit from che, Apr 20, 2007

this says it best from MB, Apr 18, 2003

Re: this says it best from Tashtigo707, Apr 22, 2003

homophobia? from fireal, Apr 23, 2003

Re: homophobia? from Perfume V, May 1, 2003

Re: homophobia? from fireal, May 11, 2003

Re: homophobia? from Perfume V, Jun 13, 2003

Re: homophobia? from movie viewer, Dec 3, 2003

Re: homophobia? from Joshua, Dec 3, 2003

Re: homophobia? from Bjoern H, Dec 7, 2003

Re: homophobia? from Ronin, Jan 2, 2004

Re: homophobia? from Jaime, May 7, 2007

Re: homophobia? from Rose, Sep 2, 2007

Re: homophobia? from Allan, Sep 13, 2008

Re: this says it best from Tony Host, Jan 18, 2007

Doing what it is suppose to! from Bruce, May 9, 2003

versirreblei from mark brant, May 14, 2003

Joshy... from monica belluci, May 24, 2003

late at night from Clara, May 31, 2003

Movie end from David, Aug 24, 2003

Joshy's point from tommy, Jun 1, 2003

[no subject] from , Sep 25, 2003

ART from L, Oct 6, 2003

Re: ART from Derek, Dec 6, 2006

I liked it... then hated it. from Bryan, Sep 29, 2003

Re: I liked it... then hated it. from Bjoern H, Dec 7, 2003

JOSHUA TANZER, You are a jackass! from sudamericanrocker, Oct 12, 2003

Re: JOSHUA TANZER, You are a jackass! from Tostitos, Oct 18, 2003

Fucking americans! from Mr. Europa, Nov 12, 2003

Re: Fucking americans! from karen, Dec 22, 2004

Re: Fucking americans! from ying, May 15, 2005

Is this a review?? from Mauro, Dec 5, 2003

the movie was a complete success. from Nadira Ilana, Jan 2, 2004

Re: Is this a review?? from Hathor, Feb 6, 2004

YOU UNEDUCATED, IGNORANT, NARROW-MINDED MORON from JamesEarlCash, Dec 8, 2003

Re: YOU UNEDUCATED, IGNORANT, NARROW-MINDED MORON from Flipper, Dec 31, 2005

got a little carried away from JamesEarlCash, Dec 8, 2003

Post Scriptum from JamesEarlCash, Dec 8, 2003

saw last night - amazing viceral from michael, Jan 6, 2004

Re: saw last night - amazing viceral from Drew, Jan 25, 2005

if you know films, this for BEST PICTURE from dobermann, Jan 13, 2004

» Irreversible « from Tyler Durden, Feb 18, 2004

Asking for a song from Pedro Trevino, Apr 5, 2004

Criminal charges from A.J.A., Apr 25, 2004

Editing from Me, Aug 1, 2004

irreversible... from Jeff, Nov 24, 2004

Re: irreversible... from Onetime, Dec 16, 2004

my sentiments exactly from RG, Jun 10, 2005

Good review from Lampen, Jun 27, 2005

Gasper Noe ROCKS from Discoelmer, Jul 5, 2005

Is this guy a qualified critic? from theevildead23, Sep 3, 2005

"Irreversible" review from Steven J Athanas, Oct 30, 2005

Eyes open from che, Nov 13, 2005

Re: Eyes open from ski, Nov 25, 2005

feedbeack from Per, Jan 10, 2006

Relax gentlemen... from JT Mengel, Jun 26, 2006

Joshua Tanzer is a stupid cunt from DNK, Jul 4, 2006

Re: Joshua Tanzer is a stupid cunt from Che, Apr 20, 2007

lol, go and watch clockwork orange from nameless, Oct 1, 2006

Memento?!?!? from Pokey, Oct 30, 2006

[no subject] from SteamMachine, Nov 16, 2006

Tanzer Sucks from Ricardo Moscoso, May 25, 2007

Hypocrite!! from Dee, Jun 19, 2007

Not at all a pointless movie from kada, Jul 12, 2007

Joshua hit the nail on the head from Mike Lep, Aug 7, 2007

Re: Joshua hit the nail on the head from Novi Filipovich, Jul 5, 2014

Movie is good and reviewer is bad... from Cheery, Sep 16, 2007

Disgusted from Sick, Jan 30, 2009

You're an idiot from Robert, May 6, 2009

inexcusable from Fin Macdonald, Oct 16, 2013

Amazing movie, Top notch from Novi Filipovich, Jul 5, 2014